Thursday, October 7, 2010

Monster

One of the main themes in Monster that Steve Harmon has to deal with is identity. Steve constantly struggles with how he sees himself: whether or not he is like the others involved in the robbery homicide, or if he is different from them. This struggle for identity contributes to the story because Steve and his attorney, O'Brien, try to convince the jury that he is not anything like Bobo Evans, Osvaldo Cruz, and James King. I think that this is very important to the story because Steve is trying to decide if he fits the stereotype of being a monster, when in his mind he has not done anything wrong and should not be on trial for this crime. But slowly the reader witnesses how Steve and his attorney  start to believe that he is just as much as a monster as the other guys are even though he did not take the money or pull the trigger of the gun that killed Mr. Nesbitt. I think that at least one point in everyone's life, we all struggle with finding our true identities, but it can be difficult to really be able to allow yourself to discover who you really are. It can be difficult because some people might think that they have to fit a certain image or stereotype. Which is why I think that Steve had such a hard time finding himself because he has to fit the mold for being a black teenage boy on trial living in Harlem, NY; which unfortunately, causes him to work harder to convince the jury that he does not fit that stereotype for the crime that occured. 

3 comments:

  1. Hey Ally :)

    I loved what you wrote. When reading the book I was very back and forth on Steve and his part take in the crime. When it comes to Steve being a "Monster" I do not believe he is, I believe that he made a bad choice, as we all have in our lives. And you are right when you say he fels though he didn't do anything wrong so should not be on trial...even though HE should. I believe he should because he did part take in some of the crime, even though he didn't kill anyone.
    And I agree when you say we all have to find our indentities at some point because you are completely right about that. I also like to take into account that Steve was only 16 at the time, he is still finding out who he is :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. He really did have to work harder to prove himself innocent to the jury because of the stereotypes we still have today. Sadly there will always be these stereotypes and racism in the world which gives people unfortunate advantages over others. It was hard for him to come to terms with who he really is when everyone else around him only sees him as a Monster.

    ReplyDelete
  3. If we are only seen by others in a certain light...and we can never "shake" that association, do we, in turn, become that person?

    Are we prisoners to the stereotypes others hold regarding us?

    ReplyDelete